AirPods Pro 1 vs 2: Key Differences and Which to Choose

Apple's AirPods Pro have become a benchmark for wireless earbuds. But when comparing the first and second generations, it can be tricky to decide which suits your needs best. This comparison digs into key differences and similarities between the two models to help you make the right choice.

AirPods Pro 1 vs 2: The Verdict

Best Overall

If you’re after the latest tech, AirPods Pro 2 might be your best bet. They bring significant upgrades in noise cancellation, battery life, and overall sound quality. The improved spatial audio features and enhanced skin-detect sensors make the second generation a standout for immersive sound.

Best by Price

When it comes to cost, AirPods Pro 1 are the more budget-friendly option. They offer solid performance and features that still hold up, making them an excellent choice if you’re looking to save money while enjoying high-quality sound.

Best for Battery Life

AirPods Pro 2 win here. With up to six hours of listening time on a single charge (compared to 4.5 hours on AirPods Pro 1), they offer more playback time before needing a recharge.

AirPods Pro 1 vs 2: Detailed Comparison

When comparing the first-generation AirPods Pro to the AirPods Pro 2, we see several important differences across key areas like sound quality, noise cancellation, design, and more. Let’s break these down in detail so you can make the most informed choice based on what matters to you.

Sound Quality

While the first-gen AirPods Pro already set a high standard, the second-gen AirPods Pro elevate the listening experience. The AirPods Pro 2 come with an updated driver and amplifier that provide deeper bass, cleaner mids, and enhanced clarity across a wider range of frequencies. This means the music, podcasts, and calls sound richer and more full-bodied. If you’re someone who values bass-heavy tracks or likes a more immersive audio experience, the AirPods Pro 2 deliver.

In addition to the sound improvements, AirPods Pro 2’s spatial audio technology takes a leap forward. Spatial audio with dynamic head tracking creates a more immersive, three-dimensional sound experience, making it feel like you’re surrounded by sound. This is especially noticeable when watching movies or playing games, where audio placement becomes more precise. Although the AirPods Pro 1 feature spatial audio, the second-generation earbuds make it more natural and engaging, amplifying the overall audio experience.

Verdict on Sound Quality: While both models offer excellent sound, the second-gen AirPods Pro outshine the original in bass depth, clarity, and immersive spatial audio. If you're looking for an upgrade in audio quality, AirPods Pro 2 will not disappoint.

Noise Cancellation

Active Noise Cancellation (ANC) was one of the standout features of the original AirPods Pro, but the AirPods Pro 2 take this feature even further. The new H2 chip in AirPods Pro 2 enhances noise cancellation by using advanced algorithms that adapt in real time to your environment. This means it blocks out more ambient noise, especially in challenging environments like busy streets, public transport, or crowded cafes. Whether it's low rumbles or high-pitched sounds, the second-gen AirPods Pro do a better job of muting distractions.

Transparency mode, which allows ambient sound to pass through while you listen, has also been refined in AirPods Pro 2. It now offers adaptive transparency, automatically lowering the volume of loud noises, like sirens or construction sounds, while still letting you hear conversations or announcements clearly.

Verdict on Noise Cancellation: If you frequently find yourself in noisy environments, the AirPods Pro 2 offer a noticeably better experience when it comes to shutting out distractions and keeping you immersed in your audio.

Design and Fit

On the surface, both the AirPods Pro 1 and 2 look very similar. The iconic white stem design remains intact, but the AirPods Pro 2 come with some refinements that improve the overall comfort. Apple added an extra ear tip size (XS), which provides a better fit for those who found the original options too large. This additional flexibility in sizing helps more users find a comfortable fit, ensuring the earbuds stay snug without causing discomfort during long listening sessions.

Although the design hasn’t drastically changed, the internal hardware in AirPods Pro 2 has been reengineered to make the buds more efficient, allowing for better airflow and improved performance. Plus, the case now features a built-in lanyard loop for easier carrying, a subtle but useful addition.

Verdict on Design and Fit: The design remains largely unchanged, but the extra ear tip size and improved ergonomics make AirPods Pro 2 the winner for those who need a more tailored fit or prioritize comfort over long periods.

Connectivity

Both AirPods Pro models connect easily to Apple devices, but the second-generation model has the advantage of Bluetooth 5.3. This upgrade offers a more stable connection, faster pairing, and less interference, which is crucial for users who experience frequent dropouts with the first-generation earbuds. Additionally, Bluetooth 5.3 allows the AirPods Pro 2 to consume less power during use, which contributes to their extended battery life (more on that below).

Another key advantage is multi-device connectivity. While both models support this feature, switching between devices (like moving from your iPhone to your Mac) feels quicker and smoother with the AirPods Pro 2, thanks to the enhanced processing power of the H2 chip.

Verdict on Connectivity: If you value a rock-solid connection and smoother transitions between Apple devices, the AirPods Pro 2 hold the edge, making them the better choice for those deeply invested in the Apple ecosystem.

Battery Life

Battery life is an area where the AirPods Pro 2 significantly outshine the first-gen model. The AirPods Pro 2 provide up to 6 hours of listening time on a single charge, which is a noticeable improvement over the 4.5 hours that the original AirPods Pro offer. With the charging case, the total listening time extends to around 30 hours with the AirPods Pro 2, compared to 24 hours with the first-generation AirPods Pro.

In addition to longer battery life, the AirPods Pro 2 charging case now features MagSafe compatibility, allowing for faster and more convenient charging. You can also use the built-in speaker in the case, which chimes when you're trying to locate it through the Find My app.

Verdict on Battery Life: AirPods Pro 2 clearly come out ahead, offering longer battery life and more convenient charging options. If battery longevity is important to you, the second-gen model is the better option.

Features

The feature set of AirPods Pro 2 has seen several upgrades over the original model. One of the most practical additions is the skin-detect sensor, which offers a more reliable way of pausing playback when the earbuds are removed. This sensor is more accurate than the optical sensors used in the AirPods Pro 1, minimizing accidental pausing.

The AirPods Pro 2 also come equipped with more advanced Find My integration. While both models can be located using the Find My app, the second-gen charging case has a built-in speaker and U1 chip, making it easier to track down if lost. This added layer of security is especially useful for those prone to misplacing their case.

The AirPods Pro 2’s case is also water and sweat-resistant (IPX4), providing extra protection against the elements, a feature that can be important for those using their earbuds during workouts or in rainy conditions.

Verdict on Features: With upgrades like skin-detect sensors, better Find My integration, and a more durable charging case, the AirPods Pro 2 offer more features that enhance the overall user experience.

Price

Price is often a deciding factor for many buyers. The first-gen AirPods Pro are now more affordable, often available at a discount from various retailers. This makes them a great option for those who want premium features like ANC and spatial audio without paying a premium price.

On the other hand, AirPods Pro 2 come with a higher price tag but deliver several key improvements that justify the cost if you’re looking for more future-proof technology. These enhancements include better sound quality, stronger noise cancellation, longer battery life, and additional features like skin-detect sensors and improved Find My functionality.

Verdict on Price: If budget is your primary concern, the first-gen AirPods Pro offer excellent value for the money. However, if you’re willing to spend a bit more for significant upgrades, the AirPods Pro 2 are worth the investment.

3 Alternatives to AirPods Pro 1 and 2 that might fit better to your needs

1. Titan: World’s 1st eSIM Connected Earbuds

Titan stands out with eSIM technology, allowing you to make calls or listen to music without your phone. They’re perfect for those who want ultimate wireless freedom while staying connected.

2. Sony WF-1000XM5

Known for their superior noise cancellation, Sony earbuds provide excellent sound quality, making them a strong competitor to AirPods Pro. Their long battery life and customizable sound settings give users a more personalized listening experience.

3. Bose QuietComfort Earbuds II

Bose is another big name in noise-cancelling technology, and their QuietComfort Earbuds II offer a robust alternative. They provide superior noise isolation and impressive sound clarity, making them ideal for frequent travelers or those who prioritize sound quality.

Conclusion

Both the AirPods Pro 1 and 2 offer fantastic features, but the choice depends on your needs. If you’re after the latest tech and enhanced features, the AirPods Pro 2 are the way to go. 

However, if you’re looking for a reliable, cost-effective option, AirPods Pro 1 still hold up as a great choice. And if neither of these quite fits, don’t forget to explore the alternatives, like Titan and other top contenders.